Welcome to Benny Palmetto's, Pizza
At Benny Palmetto's Pizza, located in the heart of Mt. Pleasant, SC, we celebrate the art of pizza-making inspired by classic New York styles. Our story began with a mission to serve delicious, oversized pies perfect for sharing. Each 28" pizza, crafted with care, features a thin, crispy crust that customers rave about, accompanied by a range of toppings. From our signature pepperoni to garlic mushroom, the flavors are bold and satisfying. Our late-night hours cater to those craving a post-drink snack, making Benny’s a beloved local spot. Join us for a slice of joy and a memorable dining experience!
-
433 W Coleman Blvd, Mt Pleasant, SC 29464 Hotline: (843) 388-4332
Welcome to the delightful world of Benny Palmetto's Pizza, where each bite is a flamboyant celebration of flavor and freshness. Nestled at 433 W Coleman Blvd, Mt Pleasant, SC 29464, this pizza haven promises an unforgettable experience, whether you're a local or just passing through.
Benny Palmetto's stands out not just for its enormous 28-inch pies, but for its community spirit, too. With options like the 28" Pepperoni Pizza, 28" Cheese Pizza, and the delectable 28" Sausage Pizza, this establishment caters to both large gatherings and late-night cravings. The prices are refreshingly reasonable, with whole pies starting at just $37.00 and plenty of toppings, such as garlic mushrooms and ranch dressing, available for your tasty customization.
- 28" Sausage Pizza - $45.00: A meaty masterpiece perfect for the hungry crowd.
- 28" Garlic Mushroom Pizza - $45.00: A savory blend of mushrooms and garlic that entices every palate.
- 28" Half and Half Pizza - $45.00: Choose your favorite toppings and divide this gigantic delight!
- 28" Cheese Pizza - $37.00: For the classic lovers out there, this pie is a guaranteed hit.
- 28" Pepperoni Pizza - $45.00: A familiar favorite, loaded with pepperoni that speaks comfort.
For those on the go or looking for a quick bite, individual slices are also available—each one gigantic and satisfying. Customers rave about the flavorful Garlic Mushroom, Sausage, and Pepperoni slices, all priced at around $7.50. Emma P., a satisfied customer, shared her experience, highlighting Benny's ability to cater to a late-night crowd with friendly service and delicious food. "Their crust is by far my favorite part," she noted, ringing true to many who savor a perfect pizza base.
The atmosphere at Benny Palmetto's is as inviting as the menu. Many diners enjoy gathering outside—either to engage in lively conversation or to soak up the social energy from nearby bars. The convenience of having drinks readily available enhances the experience, allowing you to pair your pizza with both refreshing sodas and selections of local beer.
If you're wondering about the quality, rest assured the reviews speak volumes. Many have noted Benny Palmetto's pizza resembles the beloved NY-style slices that have earned a place in many hearts. As Teresa J. celebrated, her 28" pie was not just a meal, but a joyful experience, drawing laughter and excitement from her carful of friends and family.
For a taste of Italy that transports you straight to the pizza capitals, Benny Palmetto's Pizza is the destination. Whether it's a quiet evening with friends or a lively night out, their pies are not just food; they're a feast for the senses, ready to enhance any occasion!
For inquiries, you can reach them at (843) 388-4332. Don't miss out on the experience of this Mount Pleasant gem—your perfect slice awaits!
Grabbed bennys the other night after going to shem creek and it was so easy. We just walked over because it's so close. They were about to close but were really nice and put more slices in for our big crowd. We all got pepperoni and it was a hit. This late night pizza is so yummy post drinks. Always, always get a side of ranch! Their crust is by far my favorite part but will eat it all. We sat outside on the bench and just chatted for a bit and it was nice. They also had drinks in their fridges so some of us got water while some got soda, they also serve beer but we didn't need anymore of that hahah! Thank you bennys for a late night snack!
The pizza is delicious. And HUGE. I saw some other guests at my hotel with a takeout box and I just had to find this place. It was well worth. Totally recommend.
All of the Above! Especially late Night Pizza cravings. No Seating after 1:30. Parking Lot Enjoyment is accepted
Great pizza for a great value. The slices are large!! The pizza is always fresh. They have late night hours which is nice especially because they are located by bars.
Awesome pizza by the slice and some giant pies. Quick in and out for lunch or dinner.
I have often passed this pizza shop and have wanted to try it as we love NY style pizza. We finally were able to last night and it was fantastic! We ordered ahead online for pickup and it was extremely easy to do so. Their website is easy to navigate and so is their online ordering feature. We went with a 28" pizza that had us laughing with a car full of people it was hard to get the box in! The pizza was eight HUGE slices and was enough to feed six people (four adults and two children) with two slices left over. It was delicious! The pizza is thin and having lived in New York for several years it was exactly what we remember during our time there. We went with the half cheese/half pepperoni and both were flavorful and filling. If you are wanting to feed a crowd and looking for an easy and fun meal show up with a Benny's pizza box. My kids were shocked at the size and we truly enjoyed our pizza!